Bingo Deli

Reviews

• Tim M.

  star star star star star_border 7 June 2026

  Stopped in mid-afternoon for a couple sandwiches, and as other reviews have mentioned they tend to run out of items as the afternoon goes on. They only had rye bread left, so that's what we went with (but not our first choice). Got there about 2:00pm.
  
  We had the Italian combo and New French sandwiches. Both sandwiches were freshly made and delicious. I like that most any sandwich can be made on a roll, sliced bread or a wrap. Very flexible!
  
  Also ordered the macaroni salad, but it was not to my liking. It had a strong onion powder flavor, so either there was a preparation problem or that's just the way they make it. If you decide to get it, be prepared for something out of the ordinary.
  
  I would go back and explore other sandwiches on their menu, as it looked great.

• Daniel B.

  star star star star star_border 5 June 2026

  I ordered the "Chicken Deluxe" - Chicken Cutlet with pastrami, mozzarella, lettuce and tomato on toasted wheat.  Instead of Ranch I asked for Russian.  Very good!  
  
  Place is small and fill up quick after Noon so venture out a bit earlier to avoid the lines.  The fresh carved turkey looks good too.  Will try that next.

• Ron H.

  star star star star star 30 May 2026

  This place continues to deliver! Easy to understand the choices and easy to order and checkout. I ordered the J. Wow sandwich, which had meat, avocado, lettuce, and tomato - and it was very good. I suspect all the sandwiches are good, and they have a fair number of bread choices. I couldn't complain about a thing - even the prices were normal (for a big city).
  
  Reviews on other lunch places continually report problems with quality, where to stand, how to communicate your order, etc. In short, no drama associated with this deli, and the food is great!

• Alex F.

  star star star star star_border 27 May 2026

  I really enjoy eating at bingo deli. The options are great, they have sandwiches, soups, and salads. Lots of drink options, as well as chips and candy. It's VERY small and tight inside. I try to avoid the peak hours because when ordering a sandwich it can get claustrophobic. The prices are pretty fair, and the serving sizes are good. I only gave 4 stars because I get the jwow and once they didn't put any avocado, another time they put mustard when I specifically asked for no mustard. The one guy barely talks. But aside from that I don't really have any complaints about the staff. The wait isn't too bad, and 8/10 times it's good.

• Ryan F.

  star star star star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  Had lunch at Bingo Deli on Friday afternoon. Decent sandwich, just needed fresher bread and more sauce.
  
  Quality: I decided to go with the Chicken Deluxe. It is a chicken cutlet with grilled pastrami, melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing. My sandwich was extremely light on sauce, but the other elements were good. The biggest weakness was the bread, which was not fresh and detracted from an otherwise good sandwich.
  Quantity: A solid sandwich that easily suffices for two meals.
  Value: $9.00 for a Chicken Deluxe Hero.
  Ambiance: Bingo Deli is located in the FiDi of Manhattan. The shop is pretty large, but has no actual seating inside. Instead the space just works to contain a wrap around line. The kitchen is extremely active and they also have a salad creation area.
  Crowd: A line wrapped through the shop and just outside.
  Service: Be sure to make your order complete from the start, because the staff will immediately move on to whoever is next.
  Parking: No good parking options in the area.